This started as a Facebook rant, and then ballooned into a more comprehensive dissertation on the racist history of U.S. immigration policy and citizenship generally (or as comprehensive as a dissertation can be that was written in 6 hours in a sleep-deprived state).
I’m sure I missed some important points. Feel free to reblog with relevant information and corrections. Some of this was new information to me, and I may not have understood it perfectly, or explained it well. Please copy, paste, and share any or all of this information wherever you think it might do some good. Links are provided not only as sources, but also as starting points for additional reading about any of the topics summarized below.
In summation: There is no immigration crisis in the U.S., and no real reason to be cracking down now, other than to score points with the party base, or as a distraction.
Part II: Legal Immigration Is Not A Reasonable Option For Most People
In summation: unless you have money, a lot of free time, an outstanding skill set, a keen ability to cut through red tape and navigate bureaucracy, and/or a strong family support system already established in the U.S., you can forget about immigrating legally.
Part III: The History of Immigration and Citizenship Rights in the U.S. is Racist AF, in Case You Hadn’t Heard
The
U.S. has a long history of restricting and withholding citizenship rights from people of “undesirable” ethnicities and
nationalities (usually non-white). (i.e., there is no good historical
precedent for equating legality with morality.)
In conclusion: America’s history on immigration policy and its
treatment of those it considers outsiders has always been shady as heck,
and pretending otherwise (”HOW is this happening in AMERICA????”) is blatant historical erasure.
I
do not bring up any of these things because I hate America, or think
that anyone else should, but I think we should be honest about our
history, and the suffering that history has caused, and continues to cause. We can learn from the past, and do better going forward, but only if we understand and acknowledge
what our history is and how it impacts the present. “Make America Great Again” denies the negative
aspects of our past, and is disrespectful and dismissive towards the people who remind us that America
has never been “great” for them.
Here endeth the history lesson.
English history is very similar. I’ve lived in the uk for 13 years, I’m white, degree educated and work in an in-demand job (teaching), but I’m still not an English citizen. I have indefinite leave to remain which means I took the stupid citizenship test (which is mind blowingly ridiculous and skews results to people with a very particular type of memory) and still couldn’t get my British passport because I couldn’t afford it. The price keeps increasing as well, so as the man said when I got my LTR, “oh if you JUST pay another £1000 you can get a passport” and then looked at me like a freak when I laughed and said I’d had to borrow the money to get my visa! That was 7 years ago – now the price is more like £1700 i think – still out of my price range for a little while!
The Widely Translated (and sadly accepted) Lyrics:
You pass by and become connected
You enter in and become love
Someone said that before – But I am just colored by you
The Accurate Translation (lost in translation and widely ignored):
‘You touched me, it was Fate.
I got soaked, it was Love.’
Someone had once said this (about falling in love).
But I am completely stained by you.
The Actual Meaning behind the lyrics:
Someone had once said that chance encounters are Fate. And love is like getting soaked. You can’t hide it. But in my case, I’m completely drenched and stained by your love. Because I like you that much that.
[honestly it pisses me off that people don’t even realise how wrong some of these translations are🙄]
listen i also hate those dumbass political cartoons about kids and their phones but at the same time you’re a fool if you flat out deny there are negative aspects to the way we communicate in the social media age
facebook and instagram strategically time your notifications after you post something to make you waste time scrolling. those two platforms also come to mind as being particularly performative (“look at this beautiful picture-ready thing i’m doing today”) although any social media encourages that. snapchat’s streak feature, as well as those stupid emojis next to people’s names, exist solely to suck you into using the app every day. twitter and instagram display your follower count, and facebook displays how many friends you have. tumblr cultivates a culture of oversharing, and although you can have one-on-one conversations on here, most “communication” takes the form of shouting from a soapbox. all of these things are related to the problem of privacy online, which many of us simply assume doesn’t exist and should therefore be tossed aside so that we can dissect and manufacture every detail of our selves and desires online. you can’t honestly tell me these things are of no concern for the way we understand ourselves and others, and our relationships to the world.
I love this post. Also note that social media (the Internet truly), in a way that TV hasn’t been able to achieve, allows advertisers to be more intimate and targeted than they’ve ever been before. Through platforms like Instagram and Facebook, we basically declare to them the things we desire, interact with most often, the places we go, etc…
All that information is scraped from us and used for all sorts of stuff. To get us to buy things, to get us to watch things, to sway our opinions on so many things.
Thank you! Whenever there’s one of those boring cartoons people about phone obsessions on Tumblr loser their shit and go “well people use their phones for reading! For learning! For communicating long distance! If you don’t think that’s amazing don’t talk to me” and completely ignoring the fact that people are on their phones too much for the wrong reasons and it IS damaging their mental health